1
00:00:02,306 --> 00:00:05,005
What does your mom do again? I don't know, charity stuff.
2
00:00:05,048 --> 00:00:07,050
I'm the one you call
when you can't call 911.
3
00:00:07,094 --> 00:00:09,052
Previously on The Equalizer...
4
00:00:09,096 --> 00:00:11,141
You don't work
for a charity, do you, Mom?
5
00:00:11,185 --> 00:00:12,621
No matter what I do,
I'm always your mom.
6
00:00:12,664 --> 00:00:13,578
I know that you lied to me.
7
00:00:14,492 --> 00:00:15,885
I am aStop!
8
00:00:15,928 --> 00:00:17,756
This guy's a cop.
9
00:00:17,800 --> 00:00:19,062
We'll take him out
to Youngstrom's farm.
10
00:00:19,106 --> 00:00:20,411
No one will ever know.
11
00:00:24,024 --> 00:00:25,112
Give that to the chief for me.
12
00:00:25,155 --> 00:00:27,157
I'm afraid of who
I might become.
13
00:00:28,767 --> 00:00:31,161
♪ Here we are
14
00:00:31,205 --> 00:00:34,077
♪ Under the stars...
15
00:00:34,121 --> 00:00:36,471
Okay, what about Leroy,
if it's a boy?
16
00:00:36,514 --> 00:00:38,429
Leroy? Oh, you can't be serious.
17
00:00:38,473 --> 00:00:40,388
What? It's distinguished.
18
00:00:40,431 --> 00:00:41,867
My uncle's name is Leroy.
19
00:00:41,911 --> 00:00:44,696
Your uncle is also 82 years old.
20
00:00:44,740 --> 00:00:46,481
I will not do that
to our child.
21
00:00:47,786 --> 00:00:50,006
Our child.
22
00:00:50,050 --> 00:00:51,486
♪ So far
23
00:00:51,529 --> 00:00:53,401
♪ Under the stars...
24
00:00:53,444 --> 00:00:55,185
- The food.
- No, no, no. I'll go.
25
00:00:55,229 --> 00:00:57,405
You and little Leroy stay.
26
00:00:57,448 --> 00:00:59,624
Uh-uh. I'm telling you,
Leroy is gonna come out
27
00:00:59,668 --> 00:01:01,148
with an AARP card.
28
00:01:01,191 --> 00:01:03,280
Tim Colvin?
29
00:01:03,324 --> 00:01:04,890
Yeah.
30
00:01:04,934 --> 00:01:06,675
You're under arrest
for rape and murder
31
00:01:06,718 --> 00:01:08,329
- in the first degree.
- Wait, wait, I'm under arrest for what?
32
00:01:08,372 --> 00:01:09,939
You have the right to remain
silent, anything you say
33
00:01:09,982 --> 00:01:11,158
can and will be held
against youThis isn't right.
34
00:01:11,201 --> 00:01:12,289
- in a court of law.
- You got the wrong guy.
35
00:01:12,333 --> 00:01:14,117
Stop! He-he didn't do anything!
36
00:01:14,161 --> 00:01:15,292
We'll figure this out.
- I love you.
- Tim?
37
00:01:15,336 --> 00:01:17,468
I love you! Tim!
38
00:01:22,473 --> 00:01:25,520
If, after considering
the testimony and evidence,
39
00:01:25,563 --> 00:01:28,088
you find that the defendant
did commit the offenses
40
00:01:28,131 --> 00:01:30,220
of rape and murder
in the first degree,
41
00:01:30,264 --> 00:01:33,136
then you are authorized
to find the defendant guilty.
42
00:01:33,180 --> 00:01:35,051
If you have
any reasonable doubt,
43
00:01:35,095 --> 00:01:36,661
then you must
acquit the defendant.
44
00:01:36,705 --> 00:01:38,315
The verdict must be unanimous.
45
00:01:38,359 --> 00:01:40,622
And despite the seriousness
of the alleged offenses,
46
00:01:40,665 --> 00:01:42,319
you are to consider the facts
47
00:01:42,363 --> 00:01:45,496
without sympathy
or concern for punishment.
48
00:01:49,065 --> 00:01:52,286
Well, that's nine days
we will never get back again.
49
00:01:52,329 --> 00:01:54,026
Could've been one
if they didn't insist
50
00:01:54,070 --> 00:01:55,506
on "talking lawyer."
51
00:01:55,550 --> 00:01:57,291
I don't know, I mean,
52
00:01:57,334 --> 00:01:58,640
you hear about guys like this
all the time,
53
00:01:58,683 --> 00:02:00,120
but to actually be
a part of it--
54
00:02:00,163 --> 00:02:01,121
pretty cool.
55
00:02:01,164 --> 00:02:02,948
Let me guess.
56
00:02:02,992 --> 00:02:04,254
You're obsessed with true crime.
57
00:02:04,298 --> 00:02:06,517
Excuse me?
What do you care?
58
00:02:06,561 --> 00:02:07,779
How long do you think
we all have to be in here?
59
00:02:07,823 --> 00:02:09,172
I have work.
60
00:02:09,216 --> 00:02:10,434
Oh, we all got our lives
to get back to.
61
00:02:10,478 --> 00:02:12,349
Well, you're the foreman.
62
00:02:12,393 --> 00:02:14,134
What do you think about
taking a vote now?
63
00:02:14,177 --> 00:02:15,135
Sure.
64
00:02:15,178 --> 00:02:17,006
Let's take a vote.
65
00:02:17,049 --> 00:02:18,355
Let's do hands in the air.
66
00:02:18,399 --> 00:02:19,661
All for guilty?
67
00:02:24,883 --> 00:02:26,494
Wait. Really?
68
00:02:26,537 --> 00:02:28,539
I was gonna say the same thing.
69
00:02:28,583 --> 00:02:31,063
You really think the defense
proved this guy is innocent?
70
00:02:31,107 --> 00:02:32,587
She doesn't have to.
71
00:02:32,630 --> 00:02:35,546
The prosecution has to prove
that he's guilty
72
00:02:35,590 --> 00:02:37,766
beyond a reasonable doubt,
73
00:02:37,809 --> 00:02:38,897
and I have one.
74
00:02:38,941 --> 00:02:40,203
He's clearly guilty.
75
00:02:40,247 --> 00:02:42,031
He admitted to being
at the scene.
76
00:02:42,074 --> 00:02:43,772
He was spotted running away
77
00:02:43,815 --> 00:02:45,817
right after the victim's
time of death.
78
00:02:45,861 --> 00:02:48,168
He admitted to being in
the building, not at the scene,
79
00:02:48,211 --> 00:02:50,605
and haven't you ever run
for a cab?
80
00:02:50,648 --> 00:02:52,607
What about his violent history?
81
00:02:52,650 --> 00:02:53,999
The argument with his fiancée?
82
00:02:54,043 --> 00:02:55,392
The cut on his arm?
83
00:02:55,436 --> 00:02:57,916
Right, from struggling
with the victim.
84
00:02:57,960 --> 00:02:59,222
Weren't you listening
to the evidence?
85
00:02:59,266 --> 00:03:00,528
I was.
86
00:03:00,571 --> 00:03:02,617
He said he got the cut
87
00:03:02,660 --> 00:03:06,011
from tripping on the street, and...
88
00:03:06,055 --> 00:03:08,318
it was on his hand, not his arm.
89
00:03:08,362 --> 00:03:10,625
Does it matter
- where the cut was?
- Maybe.
90
00:03:10,668 --> 00:03:12,235
Look, I'm not sure
91
00:03:12,279 --> 00:03:13,802
of his innocence,
but what I do know is that
92
00:03:13,845 --> 00:03:16,979
if we vote to convict,
93
00:03:17,022 --> 00:03:19,024
a human being goes to prison
94
00:03:19,068 --> 00:03:21,418
for the rest of his life.
95
00:03:21,462 --> 00:03:23,681
So he deserves to have us
take a hard look
96
00:03:23,725 --> 00:03:26,206
at the facts.
97
00:03:26,249 --> 00:03:29,209
The least we could do is start
by getting them straight.
98
00:03:32,212 --> 00:03:34,475
Mom. Hey, where's my red hoodie?
99
00:03:34,518 --> 00:03:36,433
I want to wear it to Dad's
this weekend.
100
00:03:36,477 --> 00:03:38,870
It is in the laundry room.
101
00:03:38,914 --> 00:03:42,222
And you know that machine is
not password protected, right?
102
00:03:42,265 --> 00:03:43,832
When's Aunt Vi done
with jury duty again?
103
00:03:45,094 --> 00:03:47,444
What does that have to do
with you helping out around here
104
00:03:47,488 --> 00:03:48,576
before you go to your dad's?
105
00:03:49,838 --> 00:03:51,535
By the way...
106
00:03:51,579 --> 00:03:53,624
how are you feeling about
seeing your dad?
107
00:03:53,668 --> 00:03:55,365
What do you mean?
108
00:03:56,845 --> 00:03:59,064
These questions
he's been asking you about me,
109
00:03:59,108 --> 00:04:00,675
about what I'm involved in.
110
00:04:00,718 --> 00:04:03,286
I mean, I'm-I'm fine.
111
00:04:03,330 --> 00:04:04,722
Well, if I have to lie
to keep your secret...
112
00:04:07,029 --> 00:04:08,422
I know how to handle Dad.
113
00:04:10,293 --> 00:04:12,121
Well...
114
00:04:13,427 --> 00:04:15,646
Don't start trying that
around here.
115
00:04:15,690 --> 00:04:16,995
What?
116
00:04:17,039 --> 00:04:18,432
What? No way.
117
00:04:18,475 --> 00:04:19,824
Would never.
118
00:04:19,868 --> 00:04:21,435
Yeah, never. That's right.
119
00:04:21,478 --> 00:04:23,480
Hey, Aunt Vi.
120
00:04:23,524 --> 00:04:25,003
You look exhausted.
121
00:04:25,047 --> 00:04:26,266
Locked in a room
122
00:04:26,309 --> 00:04:28,311
for hours with 11 strangers.
123
00:04:28,355 --> 00:04:29,878
Can't imagine why.
124
00:04:29,921 --> 00:04:31,314
Five minutes in, they're ready
125
00:04:31,358 --> 00:04:32,576
to send this young man
away for life,
126
00:04:32,620 --> 00:04:34,274
with no discussion.
127
00:04:34,317 --> 00:04:36,276
Hell no.
128
00:04:36,319 --> 00:04:38,103
I will get
these people talking.
129
00:04:38,147 --> 00:04:40,410
I will keep them there till
winter if that's what it takes.
130
00:04:40,454 --> 00:04:42,847
Well, guess I got
some laundry to do.
131
00:04:42,891 --> 00:04:43,805
Thank you.
132
00:04:45,763 --> 00:04:47,852
The arrogance of these people.
133
00:04:47,896 --> 00:04:49,245
I mean,
134
00:04:49,289 --> 00:04:50,507
I don't know
if he did it or not,
135
00:04:50,551 --> 00:04:52,335
but they don't either.
136
00:04:52,379 --> 00:04:54,511
And that's why
we're supposed to deliberate,
137
00:04:54,555 --> 00:04:56,818
not just declare a hung jury
138
00:04:56,861 --> 00:04:59,255
because they've already
made up their minds.
139
00:04:59,299 --> 00:05:01,649
No one likes to admit
they could be wrong.
140
00:05:01,692 --> 00:05:03,955
Means they have to
reexamine everything.
141
00:05:03,999 --> 00:05:06,393
Yes, and that's why
we're there.
142
00:05:06,436 --> 00:05:08,438
But I'm telling you
143
00:05:08,482 --> 00:05:10,353
there is something about
this evidence
144
00:05:10,397 --> 00:05:13,051
that just doesn't sit right
with me.
145
00:05:13,095 --> 00:05:14,488
It's too...
146
00:05:14,531 --> 00:05:18,187
It's too tidy.
It's too black and white.
147
00:05:18,230 --> 00:05:20,320
Well, what's the case?
148
00:05:20,363 --> 00:05:22,931
You know I can't tell you that.
149
00:05:23,975 --> 00:05:25,499
Doesn't matter.
150
00:05:25,542 --> 00:05:27,544
It's too late now, anyway.
151
00:05:28,937 --> 00:05:32,114
I just think there's
a messy truth out there that...
152
00:05:34,029 --> 00:05:36,640
I just wish someone had taken
the time to find it.
153
00:05:41,558 --> 00:05:43,517
So, she refused to give you
any details about the trial,
154
00:05:43,560 --> 00:05:45,214
and you took that as
a personal invitation
155
00:05:45,257 --> 00:05:46,389
to dig into the case?
156
00:05:46,433 --> 00:05:48,391
Well, Aunt Vi is
too smart to ask.
157
00:05:48,435 --> 00:05:49,653
But she has
really good instincts,
158
00:05:49,697 --> 00:05:51,568
and a man's life is at stake,
159
00:05:51,612 --> 00:05:54,223
so let's just make sure
the jury has all the evidence.
160
00:05:54,266 --> 00:05:55,355
You know which courthouse?
161
00:05:55,398 --> 00:05:57,095
Nah. It's somewhere
in Brooklyn.
162
00:05:57,139 --> 00:05:59,097
Brooklyn, male defendant,
life sentence.
163
00:05:59,141 --> 00:06:00,272
Hold, please.
164
00:06:01,535 --> 00:06:03,580
What's up?
165
00:06:03,624 --> 00:06:06,670
You have that
"I'm here in body only" look.
166
00:06:06,714 --> 00:06:08,411
Dee is lying again.
167
00:06:08,455 --> 00:06:10,805
Isn't that what teenagers do?
168
00:06:10,848 --> 00:06:12,894
Yeah, but she's lying
to protect me.
169
00:06:12,937 --> 00:06:14,939
To her dad.
170
00:06:14,983 --> 00:06:16,071
He's been asking questions.
171
00:06:16,114 --> 00:06:17,768
Yeah, that is tricky.
172
00:06:17,812 --> 00:06:19,640
Yeah.
173
00:06:19,683 --> 00:06:21,946
I always taught her
that lying was wrong,
174
00:06:21,990 --> 00:06:24,122
but now she's learning
it's okay,
175
00:06:24,166 --> 00:06:25,341
that it can be necessary.
176
00:06:25,385 --> 00:06:26,821
Well, she's not wrong.
177
00:06:26,864 --> 00:06:28,431
I lie about Harry being dead
for years.
178
00:06:28,475 --> 00:06:29,911
Yeah, but you're an adult.
179
00:06:29,954 --> 00:06:31,913
Delilah is a high school kid,
180
00:06:31,956 --> 00:06:33,305
and it's her father.
181
00:06:35,264 --> 00:06:36,787
Lying can be a dangerous road,
182
00:06:36,831 --> 00:06:38,485
and I'm the one
that's put her on it.
183
00:06:38,528 --> 00:06:40,617
All right, I got it.
184
00:06:40,661 --> 00:06:43,490
Defendant's name is
Tim Colvin.
185
00:06:43,533 --> 00:06:45,970
He's charged with the
rape and murder of
186
00:06:46,014 --> 00:06:48,320
Sarah Ross, a white
college undergrad.
187
00:06:48,364 --> 00:06:50,366
So, eight months ago,
188
00:06:50,410 --> 00:06:52,020
Sarah, the victim,
is drinking at the bar
189
00:06:52,063 --> 00:06:53,587
with her roommate, Olivia,
190
00:06:53,630 --> 00:06:55,458
who sees Sarah
talking to this guy, Tim.
191
00:06:55,502 --> 00:06:57,068
Olivia goes home later,
finds Sarah
192
00:06:57,112 --> 00:06:59,201
strangled and raped
in her apartment,
193
00:06:59,244 --> 00:07:01,203
and Tim is seen running away
from the building.
194
00:07:01,246 --> 00:07:02,509
And what's Tim's story?
195
00:07:02,552 --> 00:07:04,206
I mean, guy says he's innocent.
196
00:07:04,249 --> 00:07:05,642
Says the only reason
he was even in the building was,
197
00:07:05,686 --> 00:07:07,862
he was going on a walk,
he got cold.
198
00:07:07,905 --> 00:07:09,733
Spotted the vestibule
through the window upstairs.
199
00:07:09,777 --> 00:07:11,431
Building looked cozy.
200
00:07:11,474 --> 00:07:13,041
Went in there, warmed up.
201
00:07:13,084 --> 00:07:14,434
Gets a cab and goes home.
202
00:07:14,477 --> 00:07:16,392
And talking to Sarah at the bar?
203
00:07:16,436 --> 00:07:17,654
I mean, he denies even being
at the bar,
204
00:07:17,698 --> 00:07:18,829
but he's got no alibi.
205
00:07:18,873 --> 00:07:20,396
The evidence is pretty damning.
206
00:07:20,440 --> 00:07:21,963
Who is this guy?
207
00:07:22,006 --> 00:07:23,443
I mean, he's an associate
208
00:07:23,486 --> 00:07:25,096
at an investment firm.
209
00:07:25,140 --> 00:07:26,576
He's got no record.
210
00:07:26,620 --> 00:07:28,186
He just bought a condo
with his fiancée.
211
00:07:28,230 --> 00:07:29,623
They look like a nice couple.
212
00:07:29,666 --> 00:07:31,102
Aunt Vi sat through
this whole trial
213
00:07:31,146 --> 00:07:32,843
and felt that
it was full of holes.
214
00:07:32,887 --> 00:07:34,584
I want to talk to Tim's fiancée, Morgan.
215
00:07:36,456 --> 00:07:38,153
She knew him best.
Let's see what she thinks.
216
00:07:40,634 --> 00:07:42,418
- Morgan Carver?
- Yeah.
217
00:07:42,462 --> 00:07:44,507
I'm with Champions
for the Wrongfully Convicted.
218
00:07:44,551 --> 00:07:47,031
We think
your fiancé's case may
219
00:07:47,075 --> 00:07:48,990
deserve a second look.
220
00:07:51,079 --> 00:07:53,124
Are you moving?
221
00:07:53,168 --> 00:07:54,474
Not by choice.
222
00:07:56,258 --> 00:07:58,303
Uh, with the attorney bills
and the baby...
223
00:07:58,347 --> 00:08:00,305
Morgan,
224
00:08:00,349 --> 00:08:02,090
between you and I,
225
00:08:02,133 --> 00:08:04,353
what do you think happened
eight months ago?
226
00:08:04,396 --> 00:08:07,574
Tim had just learned
that he was being let go.
227
00:08:07,617 --> 00:08:10,272
And that night,
I found out that
228
00:08:10,315 --> 00:08:13,449
he'd been offered a new job
by an ex-girlfriend,
229
00:08:13,493 --> 00:08:14,842
and he hadn't told me.
230
00:08:14,885 --> 00:08:16,104
We argued.
231
00:08:16,147 --> 00:08:18,715
He left...
232
00:08:18,759 --> 00:08:21,065
but the prosecution took it
all out of context
233
00:08:21,109 --> 00:08:24,068
and made it seem like
he was so angry from being fired
234
00:08:24,112 --> 00:08:25,679
that he went out
and killed a girl.
235
00:08:25,722 --> 00:08:27,681
Even dragged his upbringing
into it,
236
00:08:27,724 --> 00:08:29,204
as if growing up
in a rough neighborhood
237
00:08:29,247 --> 00:08:30,553
makes you a monster.
238
00:08:30,597 --> 00:08:33,077
Well, didn't the defense
track his phone?
239
00:08:33,121 --> 00:08:35,689
He left his phone
at the house that night.
240
00:08:35,732 --> 00:08:38,561
He went out for a walk
to cool down.
241
00:08:38,605 --> 00:08:40,345
So no one can account
for where he went.
242
00:08:40,389 --> 00:08:42,260
He was upset.
243
00:08:42,304 --> 00:08:44,567
We've all been there.
244
00:08:44,611 --> 00:08:46,264
Morgan, I have to ask you this,
245
00:08:46,308 --> 00:08:48,702
do you believe your fiancé
246
00:08:48,745 --> 00:08:51,052
could have done
something like this?
247
00:08:52,053 --> 00:08:53,620
He didn't do it.
248
00:08:53,663 --> 00:08:56,492
I know that man
249
00:08:56,536 --> 00:08:57,754
without a shadow of a doubt,
250
00:08:57,798 --> 00:08:59,713
and he would not do
something like this.
251
00:09:02,672 --> 00:09:05,545
When I look at my son...
252
00:09:05,588 --> 00:09:07,590
I see Tim.
253
00:09:07,634 --> 00:09:09,940
What destroys me is that
254
00:09:09,984 --> 00:09:13,553
they may never see each other
outside of prison.
255
00:09:14,684 --> 00:09:15,772
If there's...
256
00:09:15,816 --> 00:09:18,296
any help that you can offer us,
257
00:09:18,340 --> 00:09:20,429
I'm begging you for it.
258
00:09:29,003 --> 00:09:30,744
♪ Yeah, yeah, can't train,
Caine 'bout to travel ♪
259
00:09:30,787 --> 00:09:33,573
♪ Haul off, I could do
the same thing, rap game... ♪
260
00:09:36,619 --> 00:09:37,620
Thinking about a career change?
261
00:09:39,579 --> 00:09:41,450
Might've missed my NBA window.
262
00:09:41,493 --> 00:09:43,365
I was actually
talking about that walk
263
00:09:43,408 --> 00:09:45,410
down memory lane.
264
00:09:45,454 --> 00:09:46,890
Thinking you want to go
back to law school?
265
00:09:48,196 --> 00:09:50,415
Lot of people make decisions
because they're running toward
266
00:09:50,459 --> 00:09:52,461
or away from their parents.
267
00:09:52,504 --> 00:09:54,594
I think I was doing both,
becoming a cop.
268
00:09:55,856 --> 00:09:57,205
I don't know if
I ever really knew
269
00:09:57,248 --> 00:09:58,728
what I wanted.
270
00:10:00,687 --> 00:10:02,819
Maybe I never really knew myself
at all.
271
00:10:03,820 --> 00:10:06,780
I think, in the end...
272
00:10:06,823 --> 00:10:10,044
we are what we can't let go of
and what can't let go of us.
273
00:10:14,657 --> 00:10:16,398
I left the force for a reason.
274
00:10:17,660 --> 00:10:19,575
I need some time to
work through things.
275
00:10:19,619 --> 00:10:21,316
And I respect that.
276
00:10:21,359 --> 00:10:23,361
All I need is a consult.
277
00:10:23,405 --> 00:10:25,146
Just give me five minutes,
278
00:10:25,189 --> 00:10:27,191
and if you don't want to be
involved, I will leave you be.
279
00:10:32,066 --> 00:10:33,458
So, what do you think?
280
00:10:33,502 --> 00:10:35,809
Solid case.
281
00:10:35,852 --> 00:10:38,289
Some of the evidence is
circumstantial, sure--
282
00:10:38,333 --> 00:10:40,988
the sedative in her system,
and Tim having a prescription.
283
00:10:41,031 --> 00:10:42,642
But without DNA
or fingerprints,
284
00:10:42,685 --> 00:10:44,556
lots of cases are built
this way.
285
00:10:44,600 --> 00:10:46,384
You know the detectives?
286
00:10:46,428 --> 00:10:48,691
They're good guys.
Casework's by the book.
287
00:10:48,735 --> 00:10:52,042
Maybe, but Tim was arrested
two days after the killing.
288
00:10:52,086 --> 00:10:53,870
No other suspects
were interviewed.
289
00:10:53,914 --> 00:10:55,655
Isn't it possible
they missed something?
290
00:10:55,698 --> 00:10:57,047
Sure.
291
00:10:57,091 --> 00:10:59,789
But sometimes
a cigar is just a cigar.
292
00:11:01,225 --> 00:11:02,792
I mean, I'd like to talk to Tim,
293
00:11:02,836 --> 00:11:05,099
but he's at trial
and in custody.
294
00:11:05,142 --> 00:11:07,667
His lawyer is the only one
allowed in to see him.
295
00:11:07,710 --> 00:11:09,843
Without my badge
I can't help with that.
296
00:11:09,886 --> 00:11:12,802
I'm also out of favors.
297
00:11:12,846 --> 00:11:15,718
And I meant what I said
about taking time.
298
00:11:15,762 --> 00:11:17,764
These questions
you want answered,
299
00:11:17,807 --> 00:11:19,853
you don't need me to ask them.
300
00:11:21,463 --> 00:11:22,507
What's there to question?
301
00:11:22,551 --> 00:11:24,814
The prosecution's case is solid.
302
00:11:24,858 --> 00:11:26,729
It's Tim's story
that is shaky as hell.
303
00:11:26,773 --> 00:11:28,513
I found it to be believable.
304
00:11:28,557 --> 00:11:30,211
Which part was
the most believable?
305
00:11:30,254 --> 00:11:31,647
Him taking a walk
306
00:11:31,691 --> 00:11:33,344
and conveniently forgetting
where he went?
307
00:11:33,388 --> 00:11:35,085
Or the bad luck
308
00:11:35,129 --> 00:11:36,739
where he was in the building
309
00:11:36,783 --> 00:11:37,914
while a girl was being
raped and murdered?
310
00:11:37,958 --> 00:11:39,437
JI-YOON:Dude,
311
00:11:39,481 --> 00:11:40,874
sarcasm is not gonna help here.
312
00:11:40,917 --> 00:11:42,397
Let's stick to the evidence.
313
00:11:42,440 --> 00:11:43,877
Which is that
314
00:11:43,920 --> 00:11:45,879
nobody can vouch
for Tim's story.
315
00:11:45,922 --> 00:11:48,664
On the other hand,
Sarah's roommate saw Tim
316
00:11:48,708 --> 00:11:51,101
giving her a glass of water
at the bar at 11:00 p.m.
317
00:11:51,145 --> 00:11:53,495
Later, Sarah's neighbor
heard a scream,
318
00:11:53,538 --> 00:11:56,106
just as her favorite show was
starting at 11:30,
319
00:11:56,150 --> 00:11:59,544
and Tim admits to running
for the cab a-at midnight.
320
00:11:59,588 --> 00:12:01,546
What about the DNA?
321
00:12:01,590 --> 00:12:03,331
Is anyone else disturbed
by the fact
322
00:12:03,374 --> 00:12:04,854
that there's no DNA evidence?
323
00:12:04,898 --> 00:12:07,030
Oh, he made sure of that.
324
00:12:07,074 --> 00:12:09,511
Tim had a half hour
to kill Sarah
325
00:12:09,554 --> 00:12:10,686
and clean up well enough
that there was
326
00:12:10,730 --> 00:12:12,427
no evidence left behind.
327
00:12:12,470 --> 00:12:14,342
The timeline makes sense.
328
00:12:14,385 --> 00:12:17,345
We can go around
and around all day.
329
00:12:17,388 --> 00:12:20,130
I have no doubt in my mind
that this man killed Sarah Ross.
330
00:12:20,174 --> 00:12:21,566
Why?
331
00:12:21,610 --> 00:12:23,133
This man with no record,
332
00:12:23,177 --> 00:12:25,614
with everything going for him,
what is his motive?
333
00:12:25,657 --> 00:12:28,573
I don't know if getting fired is
having everything going for you.
334
00:12:28,617 --> 00:12:30,140
The guy was pissed.
335
00:12:30,184 --> 00:12:31,838
He's riled up after the fight.
336
00:12:31,881 --> 00:12:33,491
He sees a white woman
337
00:12:33,535 --> 00:12:35,624
who looks just like the boss
who fired him,
338
00:12:35,667 --> 00:12:36,886
and he takes his rage out
on her.
339
00:12:36,930 --> 00:12:38,975
You can take 'em out
of the hood...
340
00:12:39,019 --> 00:12:41,412
Well. That seems a little... What?
341
00:12:41,456 --> 00:12:43,153
I don't know, problematic.
342
00:12:43,197 --> 00:12:45,503
And what would you know
about it, Connecticut?
343
00:12:45,547 --> 00:12:47,854
Now, he went from having nothing
344
00:12:47,897 --> 00:12:49,420
to everything.
345
00:12:49,464 --> 00:12:50,813
No wonder he feels so entitled.
346
00:12:50,857 --> 00:12:52,597
And he's the reason
men are being forced
347
00:12:52,641 --> 00:12:53,816
into early retirement.
348
00:12:53,860 --> 00:12:54,904
You mean men like you?
349
00:12:56,340 --> 00:12:59,126
Okay.
350
00:12:59,169 --> 00:13:02,825
Since we're all spinning stories
about who he might be,
351
00:13:02,869 --> 00:13:03,826
I'd like to try one
352
00:13:03,870 --> 00:13:05,741
that isn't based on
353
00:13:05,785 --> 00:13:07,830
a tired stereotype.
354
00:13:07,874 --> 00:13:09,832
How about Tim Colvin
355
00:13:09,876 --> 00:13:12,530
is a levelheaded young man
who walks away from an argument
356
00:13:12,574 --> 00:13:14,010
before it gets too heated?
357
00:13:14,054 --> 00:13:16,317
We know he's upset
with his fiancée,
358
00:13:16,360 --> 00:13:18,188
who's Black.
359
00:13:18,232 --> 00:13:20,364
Why not go out and kill someone
who looks like her?
360
00:13:20,408 --> 00:13:22,845
That same fiancée,
I might add,
361
00:13:22,889 --> 00:13:26,196
was standing by him
every day in court.
362
00:13:26,240 --> 00:13:29,765
Yeah, but can you ever
really know someone?
363
00:13:29,809 --> 00:13:31,941
I had an ex
who cured me of that. Hmm.
364
00:13:31,985 --> 00:13:34,552
If my husband was ever accused
of something like this,
365
00:13:34,596 --> 00:13:36,467
I'd put him
in the chair myself.
366
00:13:37,817 --> 00:13:39,427
And this idea that-that Tim
367
00:13:39,470 --> 00:13:43,126
drugged Sarah
with a glass of water...
368
00:13:43,170 --> 00:13:45,563
If he was so upset
when he left the house
369
00:13:45,607 --> 00:13:47,130
he forgot his phone,
370
00:13:47,174 --> 00:13:50,873
why would he think to bring
a Vexinax?
371
00:13:50,917 --> 00:13:52,614
He could've had one
in his pocket.
372
00:13:52,657 --> 00:13:54,355
He dissolves it
in the glass of water,
373
00:13:54,398 --> 00:13:56,487
hands it to Sarah-- easy.
374
00:13:56,531 --> 00:13:58,054
Vexinax doesn't dissolve.
375
00:14:00,709 --> 00:14:02,189
I got a prescription for it
376
00:14:02,232 --> 00:14:03,886
when I was going
through my divorce.
377
00:14:03,930 --> 00:14:06,193
I don't like taking pills,
so I tried it once.
378
00:14:06,236 --> 00:14:08,108
Didn't work. Wait.
379
00:14:08,151 --> 00:14:11,024
So that means he would've had to
be carrying a Vexinax pill
380
00:14:11,067 --> 00:14:12,764
that he'd already crushed up
when he saw Sarah.
381
00:14:12,808 --> 00:14:13,765
So?
382
00:14:13,809 --> 00:14:15,419
That doesn't exactly line up
383
00:14:15,463 --> 00:14:16,943
with the prosecution's story
384
00:14:16,986 --> 00:14:19,162
that this was a crime
of opportunity.
385
00:14:19,206 --> 00:14:20,598
You knew this all along.
386
00:14:21,730 --> 00:14:24,080
Why would you vote guilty?
387
00:14:24,124 --> 00:14:26,169
There was so much
other evidence.
388
00:14:26,213 --> 00:14:29,477
He was seen at the bar.
He was at her building.
389
00:14:29,520 --> 00:14:31,653
No, no, no, no. She's right.
390
00:14:31,696 --> 00:14:33,220
So, the prosecution was wrong
about it being
391
00:14:33,263 --> 00:14:34,438
a crime of opportunity.
392
00:14:34,482 --> 00:14:36,658
So what?
393
00:14:36,701 --> 00:14:38,660
So now I'm wondering
what else they were wrong about.
394
00:14:41,968 --> 00:14:43,752
The thing I keep
bumping up against is,
395
00:14:43,795 --> 00:14:46,015
why would Sarah take a pill
from a total stranger?
396
00:14:46,059 --> 00:14:47,669
They're assuming
he spiked her drink.
397
00:14:47,712 --> 00:14:49,976
No, I looked it up.
Vexinax isn't soluble.
398
00:14:51,281 --> 00:14:52,630
I wonder if the jury knows that.
399
00:14:52,674 --> 00:14:54,719
And would a prescription
antianxiety pill
400
00:14:54,763 --> 00:14:55,851
be his drug of choice?
401
00:14:55,895 --> 00:14:57,635
I mean, Rohypnol, GHB,
402
00:14:57,679 --> 00:14:59,550
even ketamine would be
better options.
403
00:14:59,594 --> 00:15:01,422
Well, it got into her system somehow.
404
00:15:01,465 --> 00:15:02,858
And, according to
the police report,
405
00:15:02,902 --> 00:15:04,642
Sarah didn't have
a prescription.
406
00:15:04,686 --> 00:15:06,557
Either she took it willingly
or somebody slipped it to her,
407
00:15:06,601 --> 00:15:08,081
and if it wasn't Tim,
then who was it?
408
00:15:08,124 --> 00:15:11,388
We need to know
who Sarah saw that night,
409
00:15:11,432 --> 00:15:14,957
and if she spent time
with anyone else at that bar.
410
00:15:15,001 --> 00:15:15,915
She was there
with her roommate, Olivia.
411
00:15:15,958 --> 00:15:18,134
Maybe she can shed some light.
412
00:15:19,135 --> 00:15:20,484
Olivia Simmons?
413
00:15:21,703 --> 00:15:23,748
Cynthia Westfield.
D.A.'s office.
414
00:15:23,792 --> 00:15:25,141
Can we talk?
415
00:15:27,317 --> 00:15:29,102
No, it was just us at the bar.
416
00:15:29,145 --> 00:15:31,843
The place was filled
with finance bros.
417
00:15:31,887 --> 00:15:34,063
Not our scene.
418
00:15:34,107 --> 00:15:35,978
So, other than Tim Colvin, you
didn't see her with anyone else?
419
00:15:37,023 --> 00:15:39,721
No. Why?
420
00:15:39,764 --> 00:15:41,157
New evidence has come to light
421
00:15:41,201 --> 00:15:42,942
about how the Vexinax got
into her system.
422
00:15:44,813 --> 00:15:46,815
What'd you mean that
it wasn't your scene?
423
00:15:47,947 --> 00:15:51,167
We were just looking to chill,
424
00:15:51,211 --> 00:15:53,865
then the place got packed
for the game.
425
00:15:53,909 --> 00:15:56,172
Not a fan of crowds, huh?
426
00:15:56,216 --> 00:15:58,696
Guys yelling.
Everybody bumping into you.
427
00:15:58,740 --> 00:16:00,742
Must've been stressful.
428
00:16:02,004 --> 00:16:04,137
We think Sarah may have
gotten the pills
429
00:16:04,180 --> 00:16:05,747
from someone
she might have trusted.
430
00:16:07,401 --> 00:16:09,838
Olivia, I'm not a cop.
431
00:16:09,881 --> 00:16:11,709
And you were never asked about
432
00:16:11,753 --> 00:16:13,059
where Sarah got the drugs,
433
00:16:13,102 --> 00:16:15,017
so technically,
you didn't lie.
434
00:16:15,061 --> 00:16:18,281
But you didn't exactly tell
the whole truth, did you?
435
00:16:18,325 --> 00:16:20,980
The crowd was
making Sarah anxious,
436
00:16:21,023 --> 00:16:23,983
so I gave her one of my pills.
437
00:16:24,026 --> 00:16:25,985
And you didn't say anything because...
438
00:16:26,028 --> 00:16:27,899
Everyone would've thought
it was my fault.
439
00:16:27,943 --> 00:16:30,337
Maybe if I hadn't given it
to her,
440
00:16:30,380 --> 00:16:32,556
she wouldn't have been
so vulnerable.
441
00:16:34,384 --> 00:16:35,733
Maybe she would still be alive.
442
00:16:35,777 --> 00:16:37,648
I just thought that
443
00:16:37,692 --> 00:16:39,346
since they got the guy...
444
00:16:39,389 --> 00:16:42,218
What made you so sure
that Tim was the guy,
445
00:16:42,262 --> 00:16:43,741
knowing he didn't give her
the drugs?
446
00:16:43,785 --> 00:16:45,961
He was in our building.
447
00:16:46,005 --> 00:16:49,399
The cops showed me his picture.
I recognized him.
448
00:16:49,443 --> 00:16:52,054
How many drinks had you had
when you saw them talking?
449
00:16:52,098 --> 00:16:54,143
Not too many because I-I...
450
00:16:54,187 --> 00:16:56,145
'Cause you had taken a Vexinax, too.
451
00:16:58,365 --> 00:17:00,193
You're still sure it was him?
452
00:17:00,236 --> 00:17:02,804
He was at our building.
453
00:17:02,847 --> 00:17:04,327
He's the guy.
454
00:17:06,025 --> 00:17:07,200
Right?
455
00:17:08,897 --> 00:17:09,854
It bears questioning.
456
00:17:09,898 --> 00:17:11,334
I've had my doubts
457
00:17:11,378 --> 00:17:12,683
about the eyewitness account
from the start.
458
00:17:12,727 --> 00:17:15,599
It was dim in the bar
and dark outside.
459
00:17:15,643 --> 00:17:17,079
She has twenty-twenty vision.
460
00:17:17,123 --> 00:17:18,646
They made a point of that.
461
00:17:18,689 --> 00:17:21,170
She was also 30 feet away
through a crowded bar.
462
00:17:21,214 --> 00:17:23,607
Olivia also testified,
under oath,
463
00:17:23,651 --> 00:17:25,870
that it was Tim she saw
talking to Sarah.
464
00:17:25,914 --> 00:17:27,872
She has no doubt in her mind.
465
00:17:27,916 --> 00:17:28,873
Are you saying she's lying?
466
00:17:28,917 --> 00:17:30,875
No, but what I am saying is that
467
00:17:30,919 --> 00:17:34,401
maybe she believed she saw
something that she didn't.
468
00:17:34,444 --> 00:17:37,447
The girl was traumatized from
finding her friend murdered.
469
00:17:37,491 --> 00:17:40,363
A police officer shows her
a photo of a Black suspect.
470
00:17:40,407 --> 00:17:43,236
The man Sarah was talking to
at the bar is Black.
471
00:17:43,279 --> 00:17:45,847
Her brain fills in the rest.
472
00:17:45,890 --> 00:17:48,415
Oh, so now we're just
making up reasons
473
00:17:48,458 --> 00:17:50,243
why the evidence
doesn't point to him.
474
00:17:50,286 --> 00:17:51,940
No, we're just looking
at possibilities,
475
00:17:51,983 --> 00:17:53,115
and we haven't even
taken into account
476
00:17:53,159 --> 00:17:55,030
that cross-racial
identifications
477
00:17:55,074 --> 00:17:57,380
are historically inaccurate.
478
00:17:57,424 --> 00:17:59,817
"Cross-racial identifications"?
479
00:17:59,861 --> 00:18:02,603
Uh, she is saying that
all white people are so racist
480
00:18:02,646 --> 00:18:04,909
that they can't
tell Black people apart.
481
00:18:04,953 --> 00:18:06,824
That is not what I'm saying.
482
00:18:06,868 --> 00:18:08,435
And for the record,
I'm insulted.
483
00:18:08,478 --> 00:18:11,133
Howard, this is not
a personal attack.
484
00:18:11,177 --> 00:18:14,180
It is just the way
our brains work.
485
00:18:14,223 --> 00:18:15,529
She's right.
486
00:18:15,572 --> 00:18:17,052
42% of wrongful convictions
487
00:18:17,096 --> 00:18:18,836
based on eyewitness testimonies
488
00:18:18,880 --> 00:18:20,621
are cross-racial
misidentifications.
489
00:18:21,926 --> 00:18:23,276
How do you know that?
490
00:18:23,319 --> 00:18:24,886
I saw an infographic
on Instagram.
491
00:18:24,929 --> 00:18:26,496
So, what?
492
00:18:26,540 --> 00:18:28,150
Now you think this guy's
innocent, too?
493
00:18:28,194 --> 00:18:30,152
I don't know.
494
00:18:33,024 --> 00:18:33,982
She was your age, you know.
495
00:18:35,288 --> 00:18:36,767
The girl
496
00:18:36,811 --> 00:18:38,465
who was raped
and strangled to death.
497
00:18:39,770 --> 00:18:40,989
And you're ready
498
00:18:41,032 --> 00:18:42,556
to let her killer go free.
499
00:18:44,514 --> 00:18:46,908
Or maybe you are,
by convicting an innocent man.
500
00:18:50,346 --> 00:18:54,133
Well, Olivia saw someone
talking to Sarah that night.
501
00:18:57,179 --> 00:18:58,746
All right, this is everybody
who used a credit card
502
00:18:58,789 --> 00:19:00,356
at the bar that night.
503
00:19:00,400 --> 00:19:03,533
No Tim and no one Olivia
would mistake for Tim.
504
00:19:03,577 --> 00:19:04,882
Any company cards?
505
00:19:04,926 --> 00:19:06,884
Uh, yeah. There's a couple.
506
00:19:06,928 --> 00:19:08,190
Any big tabs?
507
00:19:08,234 --> 00:19:09,887
This one's over a grand.
508
00:19:09,931 --> 00:19:11,324
They may have been
having a party.
509
00:19:11,367 --> 00:19:13,282
Harry, check the company roster.
510
00:19:13,326 --> 00:19:15,545
See if there's anyone
who might've been at that party
511
00:19:15,589 --> 00:19:17,808
who could've been mistaken
for Tim Colvin.
512
00:19:22,726 --> 00:19:24,815
Devin Ellis?
513
00:19:24,859 --> 00:19:26,991
- You got a minute?
- What the hell?
514
00:19:27,035 --> 00:19:28,863
Hey, do you remember going to
a company party
515
00:19:28,906 --> 00:19:30,517
about eight months ago?
516
00:19:30,560 --> 00:19:32,823
At a bar downtown
called The King George.
517
00:19:32,867 --> 00:19:34,608
You recall talking to
a blonde girl outside?
518
00:19:37,132 --> 00:19:39,178
Sarah Ross.
This is the picture
519
00:19:39,221 --> 00:19:40,353
they showed of her
all over the news
520
00:19:40,396 --> 00:19:42,268
when she was murdered
later that night.
521
00:19:42,311 --> 00:19:44,008
Why? Who are you?
522
00:19:44,052 --> 00:19:45,184
Friend of the family.
523
00:19:45,227 --> 00:19:46,750
And before you say anything,
524
00:19:46,794 --> 00:19:47,838
I talked to your colleagues,
525
00:19:47,882 --> 00:19:49,797
so I know you were there.
526
00:19:51,233 --> 00:19:54,584
Look, I talked to her, okay?
527
00:19:54,628 --> 00:19:56,238
Frankly, she looked wasted,
528
00:19:56,282 --> 00:19:57,935
so I offered her
a glass of water,
529
00:19:57,979 --> 00:20:00,286
but I had nothing to do
with her murder.
530
00:20:00,329 --> 00:20:03,202
Ask anyone I work with,
they'll tell you.
531
00:20:03,245 --> 00:20:05,247
I was at the party
when she was killed.
532
00:20:05,291 --> 00:20:07,206
Sounds like you've given this
a lot of thought.
533
00:20:07,249 --> 00:20:09,860
You heard about the murder
back then.
534
00:20:09,904 --> 00:20:12,907
You knew this whole case was
being built on bad information.
535
00:20:12,950 --> 00:20:15,257
Why wouldn't you come forward
when you knew you had an alibi?
536
00:20:15,301 --> 00:20:16,737
You think an alibi means a damn
537
00:20:16,780 --> 00:20:18,347
when they got
a dead white woman?
538
00:20:18,391 --> 00:20:20,262
I can easily be the one
on trial today.
539
00:20:20,306 --> 00:20:21,524
But you're not.
540
00:20:21,568 --> 00:20:23,047
And at any minute,
541
00:20:23,091 --> 00:20:24,353
an innocent man could be
sent to prison
542
00:20:24,397 --> 00:20:26,747
for something he didn't do.
543
00:20:26,790 --> 00:20:28,531
I'm sorry,
544
00:20:28,575 --> 00:20:30,925
but I got a family who needs me.
545
00:20:30,968 --> 00:20:33,232
If you want to help your guy,
you got to do it on your own.
546
00:20:44,678 --> 00:20:46,984
D.A. Grafton's agreed to meet
with me tomorrow morning.
547
00:20:47,028 --> 00:20:49,117
Maybe she can intercede
with the prosecutor.
548
00:20:49,160 --> 00:20:51,902
Well, you did just punch
a giant hole in the case.
549
00:20:51,946 --> 00:20:54,296
Yeah, but Devin still won't
come forward,
550
00:20:54,340 --> 00:20:56,124
even though his alibi
checked out.
551
00:20:56,167 --> 00:20:57,256
Can't say I blame him.
552
00:20:57,299 --> 00:20:58,779
And if it wasn't
for your aunt,
553
00:20:58,822 --> 00:21:00,259
"not talking to you"
about the trial,
554
00:21:00,302 --> 00:21:01,390
we wouldn't even know that.
555
00:21:01,434 --> 00:21:02,826
Does your aunt know
how right she was
556
00:21:02,870 --> 00:21:03,566
to fight for this guy?
557
00:21:03,610 --> 00:21:05,829
Not yet.
558
00:21:05,873 --> 00:21:09,485
But Aunt Vi has never needed
a reason to do what's right.
559
00:21:09,529 --> 00:21:11,008
What time is it?
560
00:21:12,271 --> 00:21:13,881
7:30.
561
00:21:13,924 --> 00:21:16,100
We're just going nowhere fast.
562
00:21:16,144 --> 00:21:19,278
I say we go home,
get some sleep.
563
00:21:19,321 --> 00:21:21,584
Come back at this fresh tomorrow.
564
00:21:21,628 --> 00:21:23,456
You know, some of us have jobs.
565
00:21:25,196 --> 00:21:26,328
Why don't we just
tell the judge the truth:
566
00:21:26,372 --> 00:21:28,156
we're deadlocked.
567
00:21:28,199 --> 00:21:30,071
He'll get a new trial,
be found guilty, like he should.
568
00:21:30,114 --> 00:21:32,421
You think you can't afford
to miss a day's work?
569
00:21:33,727 --> 00:21:35,816
Try paying a defense attorney
for a second trial.
570
00:21:35,859 --> 00:21:37,296
You know what?
571
00:21:37,339 --> 00:21:38,819
I think you have
too much time on your hands.
572
00:21:38,862 --> 00:21:39,994
You might not want to get
back to your husband,
573
00:21:40,037 --> 00:21:41,430
but the rest of us do.
574
00:21:41,474 --> 00:21:42,301
I don't have a husband, sweetheart.
575
00:21:42,344 --> 00:21:43,389
I'm not married.
576
00:21:43,432 --> 00:21:44,912
Yes, you do. You said...
577
00:21:44,955 --> 00:21:46,174
That was me.
578
00:21:46,217 --> 00:21:47,697
The other Black woman.
579
00:21:48,959 --> 00:21:50,744
Really?
580
00:21:51,832 --> 00:21:53,747
No.
581
00:21:53,790 --> 00:21:55,226
We've been together two weeks,
and you just...
582
00:21:55,270 --> 00:21:56,837
confused us.
583
00:22:00,057 --> 00:22:02,146
Which is my point.
584
00:22:03,887 --> 00:22:04,932
Isn't it possible
585
00:22:04,975 --> 00:22:07,369
that Sarah's roommate
586
00:22:07,413 --> 00:22:09,458
misidentified Tim?
587
00:22:11,765 --> 00:22:14,637
That she saw
a different Black man
588
00:22:14,681 --> 00:22:16,770
talking to Sarah that night?
589
00:22:18,032 --> 00:22:21,992
And isn't it possible
that when Tim says
590
00:22:22,036 --> 00:22:25,344
he wasn't at that bar,
591
00:22:25,387 --> 00:22:28,738
that he's actually
telling the truth?
592
00:22:32,046 --> 00:22:34,309
Well, there she goes
again, playing the race card.
593
00:22:34,353 --> 00:22:36,703
This is about race.
594
00:22:36,746 --> 00:22:40,402
This is a Black man on trial
for raping a white woman.
595
00:22:40,446 --> 00:22:43,100
No, this is about a man
596
00:22:43,144 --> 00:22:45,364
who was seen running
from a building
597
00:22:45,407 --> 00:22:47,104
where a girl was killed inside.
598
00:22:47,148 --> 00:22:48,802
Now,
599
00:22:48,845 --> 00:22:51,413
we were instructed to be honest,
600
00:22:51,457 --> 00:22:53,720
conscientious and unbiased.
601
00:22:53,763 --> 00:22:56,940
And now you're dragging
his race into it.
602
00:22:56,984 --> 00:23:00,944
To be intentionally blind to
the historical precedent here
603
00:23:00,988 --> 00:23:03,556
is the most dangerous bias
of all.
604
00:23:03,599 --> 00:23:05,296
And what about you?
605
00:23:05,340 --> 00:23:07,429
Isn't it possible
606
00:23:07,473 --> 00:23:10,084
that you have
some baggage of your own
607
00:23:10,127 --> 00:23:13,043
that is making you overlook
some pretty damning evidence?
608
00:23:13,087 --> 00:23:15,568
And isn't it possible
609
00:23:15,611 --> 00:23:17,308
that this is about
you being a Black woman,
610
00:23:17,352 --> 00:23:19,441
trying to protect her own?
611
00:23:19,485 --> 00:23:22,401
And wouldn't it be a shame
612
00:23:22,444 --> 00:23:26,056
if we didn't convict
a rapist and a murderer
613
00:23:26,100 --> 00:23:29,146
because your bias
got in the way?
614
00:23:34,587 --> 00:23:36,153
That you, Auntie?
615
00:23:36,197 --> 00:23:38,721
Boy, they got you working
like crazy down there.
616
00:23:39,940 --> 00:23:42,116
Hey.
617
00:23:42,159 --> 00:23:43,465
Come here. Sit down.
618
00:23:44,858 --> 00:23:46,990
- What happened?
- Nothing yet.
619
00:23:47,034 --> 00:23:48,470
No decision.
620
00:23:48,514 --> 00:23:50,646
Well, at least
you got them talking.
621
00:23:50,690 --> 00:23:52,256
Yeah, well...
622
00:23:52,300 --> 00:23:54,389
maybe they shouldn't be.
623
00:23:55,390 --> 00:23:56,652
What do you mean?
624
00:23:56,696 --> 00:23:59,263
What if I'm wrong
about this guy?
625
00:23:59,307 --> 00:24:01,614
What if when I look at him,
all I see are...
626
00:24:01,657 --> 00:24:04,834
are the Black men behind bars
that shouldn't be there?
627
00:24:04,878 --> 00:24:08,708
I don't want to be responsible
for setting someone free
628
00:24:08,751 --> 00:24:10,666
who may have raped
and killed a woman.
629
00:24:11,928 --> 00:24:13,495
Auntie, you know
your initial doubt
630
00:24:13,539 --> 00:24:14,801
about the prosecution's case?
631
00:24:14,844 --> 00:24:16,585
Mm-hmm.
632
00:24:17,847 --> 00:24:19,240
I would stick with it.
633
00:24:21,503 --> 00:24:23,462
Trust your gut.
634
00:24:23,505 --> 00:24:24,637
Robyn?
635
00:24:26,508 --> 00:24:27,988
I'm going to bed.
636
00:24:28,031 --> 00:24:29,816
Love you.
637
00:24:38,738 --> 00:24:40,870
Where are my boys?
638
00:24:40,914 --> 00:24:43,046
I'm afraid of
who I might become.
639
00:25:13,599 --> 00:25:15,383
What you're telling me
is concerning
640
00:25:15,426 --> 00:25:16,471
but not actionable.
641
00:25:16,515 --> 00:25:17,907
The defendant was
at the building
642
00:25:17,951 --> 00:25:18,865
where and when
the murder took place,
643
00:25:18,908 --> 00:25:19,953
by his own admission.
644
00:25:19,996 --> 00:25:21,171
But not at the bar.
645
00:25:21,215 --> 00:25:22,738
The jury is deciding
646
00:25:22,782 --> 00:25:25,828
this man's fate based off
a faulty narrative.
647
00:25:25,872 --> 00:25:27,264
I'm sympathetic,
648
00:25:27,308 --> 00:25:28,788
and the narrative
might be imperfect,
649
00:25:28,831 --> 00:25:29,702
but there are other aspects
of the case
650
00:25:29,745 --> 00:25:31,355
that tie him to the crime.
651
00:25:31,399 --> 00:25:33,444
If he is unfairly convicted,
he can appeal.
652
00:25:33,488 --> 00:25:35,969
You're joking, right?
653
00:25:36,012 --> 00:25:38,972
Only thing harder than winning
an appeal is being granted one.
654
00:25:40,626 --> 00:25:42,976
Unless you can find
exculpatory evidence
655
00:25:43,019 --> 00:25:44,586
that Tim Colvin didn't kill
656
00:25:44,630 --> 00:25:46,545
Sarah Ross,
657
00:25:46,588 --> 00:25:48,068
there's nothing I can do.
658
00:25:50,679 --> 00:25:51,724
I'm sorry.
659
00:25:54,944 --> 00:25:56,555
Unreal.
660
00:25:56,598 --> 00:25:58,339
Trials really are about
who spins the best story.
661
00:25:58,382 --> 00:26:00,689
How are we supposed to prove
Tim didn't do this?
662
00:26:00,733 --> 00:26:02,691
By finding the person who did.
663
00:26:08,610 --> 00:26:10,873
It's hard to imagine
having your whole life
664
00:26:10,917 --> 00:26:12,745
ripped out from under you
just because you were
665
00:26:12,788 --> 00:26:13,789
in the wrong place
at the wrong time.
666
00:26:13,833 --> 00:26:15,182
And we have no way
to exonerate him
667
00:26:15,225 --> 00:26:16,618
unless we find
the real killer.
668
00:26:16,662 --> 00:26:18,098
With virtually
no evidence to go on.
669
00:26:18,141 --> 00:26:19,142
I mean, the only thing
we know at this point
670
00:26:19,186 --> 00:26:20,230
is what didn't happen.
671
00:26:20,274 --> 00:26:22,450
There's always a move.
672
00:26:22,493 --> 00:26:24,583
If the bar is not relevant,
673
00:26:24,626 --> 00:26:26,323
then it's all about
the building.
674
00:26:26,367 --> 00:26:28,674
Which key witnesses were there?
I want to talk to them.
675
00:26:28,717 --> 00:26:30,066
Well, by his own admission,
there's Tim.
676
00:26:30,110 --> 00:26:31,328
I tried.
677
00:26:31,372 --> 00:26:33,243
They have him locked down.
678
00:26:33,287 --> 00:26:35,202
What about the witness
who saw him running to the cab?
679
00:26:35,245 --> 00:26:36,812
Christian Messina.
680
00:26:36,856 --> 00:26:38,248
Sarah's downstairs neighbor.
681
00:26:38,292 --> 00:26:40,686
Okay. That's our move.
682
00:26:43,210 --> 00:26:44,559
Minute to talk, Kerry?
683
00:26:44,603 --> 00:26:46,866
That depends.
684
00:26:46,909 --> 00:26:49,346
You here to put away
another one of my clients?
685
00:26:49,390 --> 00:26:50,957
Just a temperature check.
686
00:26:51,000 --> 00:26:53,002
Tim Colvin.
687
00:26:53,046 --> 00:26:54,787
I know you go to the mat
for everyone you represent,
688
00:26:54,830 --> 00:26:56,615
but what's your honest
feeling on him?
689
00:26:56,658 --> 00:26:59,313
I think he's innocent. Why?
690
00:26:59,356 --> 00:27:01,141
Been looking into it.
691
00:27:01,184 --> 00:27:04,057
Bit late for police to be
auditing casework, isn't it?
692
00:27:05,406 --> 00:27:06,799
I'm not police anymore.
693
00:27:08,496 --> 00:27:10,367
Not after...
694
00:27:10,411 --> 00:27:12,935
The fact that all that
still goes on.
695
00:27:14,415 --> 00:27:16,286
But you left?
696
00:27:16,330 --> 00:27:17,853
What was it you said
that one time?
697
00:27:17,897 --> 00:27:19,202
If you never saw me
in court again,
698
00:27:19,246 --> 00:27:20,421
it would be too soon?
699
00:27:20,464 --> 00:27:22,205
Much as I hate to admit it,
700
00:27:22,249 --> 00:27:24,643
I'd rather bust my ass
going up against cases
701
00:27:24,686 --> 00:27:26,383
built by cops like you.
702
00:27:27,820 --> 00:27:29,473
At least it's a fair fight.
703
00:27:29,517 --> 00:27:31,562
Is it ever really fair?
704
00:27:31,606 --> 00:27:32,868
Is anything?
705
00:27:36,655 --> 00:27:38,657
How do you keep doing it?
706
00:27:38,700 --> 00:27:40,397
Knowing how the system can be?
707
00:27:42,443 --> 00:27:44,401
If not me, then who?
708
00:27:48,231 --> 00:27:50,494
Can you get me in to see Tim?
709
00:27:50,538 --> 00:27:52,235
I might know someone
who can help.
710
00:27:53,802 --> 00:27:55,282
Yeah, let me see what I can do.
711
00:27:57,545 --> 00:27:59,025
Hell of a thing.
712
00:27:59,068 --> 00:28:00,940
You know if I didn't see him
get in that cab,
713
00:28:00,983 --> 00:28:03,029
they probably would've
never tracked him down.
714
00:28:03,072 --> 00:28:04,857
I hope they throw the book
at him.
715
00:28:04,900 --> 00:28:06,989
Sarah's family does, too, Christian.
716
00:28:07,033 --> 00:28:08,295
But if he appeals,
717
00:28:08,338 --> 00:28:09,688
they want to make sure
there's nothing
718
00:28:09,731 --> 00:28:11,341
that'll surprise them
in the next trial.
719
00:28:11,385 --> 00:28:12,908
Is there anything else
720
00:28:12,952 --> 00:28:14,344
you might have seen
or heard that night?
721
00:28:14,388 --> 00:28:16,216
I said it all on the stand.
722
00:28:16,259 --> 00:28:17,739
I was home
watching the football game.
723
00:28:17,783 --> 00:28:19,088
I made myself some tea
before bed,
724
00:28:19,132 --> 00:28:20,568
and that's when I looked
out my window.
725
00:28:20,611 --> 00:28:22,222
From the basement window
in the front
726
00:28:22,265 --> 00:28:23,266
that looks out onto the street?
727
00:28:23,310 --> 00:28:24,485
That's right,
728
00:28:24,528 --> 00:28:26,269
and I saw a guy running out.
729
00:28:26,313 --> 00:28:28,619
He got in a cab,
and that was at midnight.
730
00:28:30,970 --> 00:28:32,058
Sorry.
731
00:28:32,101 --> 00:28:33,712
Landlord is a cheapskate.
732
00:28:33,755 --> 00:28:35,148
A year ago, he put
all the building lights
733
00:28:35,191 --> 00:28:37,716
on motion sensors
with ridiculously short timers.
734
00:28:37,759 --> 00:28:39,805
Anyway, cops ran the cab
and caught the guy.
735
00:28:39,848 --> 00:28:41,241
Showed me a photo
and it was him.
736
00:28:41,284 --> 00:28:42,764
End of story.
737
00:28:49,075 --> 00:28:50,772
How can you accept
738
00:28:50,816 --> 00:28:52,687
that he couldn't remember
where he walked that night?
739
00:28:52,731 --> 00:28:55,690
He said he was angry
and in his own head.
740
00:28:55,734 --> 00:28:57,736
Hasn't that
ever happened to you?
741
00:28:57,779 --> 00:28:59,650
Oh, hell, I remember
where I was that night,
742
00:28:59,694 --> 00:29:00,956
and it was eight months ago.
743
00:29:02,088 --> 00:29:03,089
Watching the Giants comeback.
744
00:29:03,132 --> 00:29:04,873
Killer game.
745
00:29:04,917 --> 00:29:06,701
Went into overtime,
- Giants intercepted?
- Yep.
746
00:29:06,745 --> 00:29:08,311
I was at the bar
late that night.
747
00:29:08,355 --> 00:29:10,183
Giants threw that Hail Mary.
748
00:29:10,226 --> 00:29:12,576
Boom. Tied it all up. Guys.
749
00:29:12,620 --> 00:29:13,708
He's right.
750
00:29:13,752 --> 00:29:15,710
Can we just focus, please?
751
00:29:15,754 --> 00:29:17,581
That Giants game did go
to overtime.
752
00:29:18,582 --> 00:29:20,280
Those games, do they air
on the same network
753
00:29:20,323 --> 00:29:22,935
as the-the show the neighbor
was watching?
754
00:29:22,978 --> 00:29:25,111
- Yeah. So, what?
- So...
755
00:29:25,154 --> 00:29:26,895
the neighbor said she heard
the scream
756
00:29:26,939 --> 00:29:30,725
from Sarah's apartment
at 11:30.
757
00:29:30,769 --> 00:29:32,640
She knew exactly
what time it was
758
00:29:32,683 --> 00:29:34,337
because that's the time
that her show normally starts.
759
00:29:34,381 --> 00:29:35,425
What are you getting at?
760
00:29:35,469 --> 00:29:36,949
It didn't start at 11:30.
761
00:29:36,992 --> 00:29:38,864
If the game went
into overtime,
762
00:29:38,907 --> 00:29:40,822
then the game
763
00:29:40,866 --> 00:29:43,303
pushed back the start
of the show.
764
00:29:44,608 --> 00:29:47,437
Which means the scream could
have happened later than 11:30.
765
00:29:47,481 --> 00:29:49,091
Way later.
766
00:29:49,135 --> 00:29:50,527
That overtime could've
easily lasted half an hour
767
00:29:50,571 --> 00:29:51,311
with all the time-outs
they called.
768
00:29:51,354 --> 00:29:52,921
Yes.
769
00:29:52,965 --> 00:29:55,968
And Tim was seen running
for a cab at midnight,
770
00:29:56,011 --> 00:29:58,361
which means
the scream could have happened
771
00:29:58,405 --> 00:30:00,755
when he was already in the cab.
772
00:30:00,799 --> 00:30:02,104
HOWARD:Look.
773
00:30:02,148 --> 00:30:04,585
We are not allowed
to look it up.
774
00:30:04,628 --> 00:30:06,848
And if it was shorter
than half an hour,
775
00:30:06,892 --> 00:30:08,981
he was still in the building
when she screamed.
776
00:30:09,024 --> 00:30:11,200
That's true.
777
00:30:11,244 --> 00:30:13,333
But that would mean
778
00:30:13,376 --> 00:30:15,465
he had to rape
and kill Sarah,
779
00:30:15,509 --> 00:30:17,598
clean the apartment
of all the evidence,
780
00:30:17,641 --> 00:30:19,252
get downstairs,
781
00:30:19,295 --> 00:30:23,169
hail a cab in mere minutes.
782
00:30:23,212 --> 00:30:24,648
Is it possible
that he did it?
783
00:30:25,954 --> 00:30:26,955
Sure.
784
00:30:26,999 --> 00:30:29,131
But is it reasonable
785
00:30:29,175 --> 00:30:31,830
to doubt that he did?
786
00:30:44,190 --> 00:30:45,669
It is.
787
00:30:45,713 --> 00:30:47,889
Oh, you got to be kidding me.
788
00:30:47,933 --> 00:30:50,500
I'm changing my vote
to "not guilty."
789
00:30:54,461 --> 00:30:56,463
Same with me.
790
00:30:56,506 --> 00:30:57,943
Me, too.
791
00:30:57,986 --> 00:30:59,422
I will, too.
792
00:30:59,466 --> 00:31:00,859
And me.
793
00:31:05,254 --> 00:31:07,778
And you're 100% sure
794
00:31:07,822 --> 00:31:09,998
he could've done all of that
795
00:31:10,042 --> 00:31:11,478
in just a few minutes?
796
00:31:21,270 --> 00:31:23,011
No.
797
00:31:23,055 --> 00:31:24,404
I'm not.
798
00:31:25,971 --> 00:31:28,321
I think we
take a break now,
799
00:31:28,364 --> 00:31:31,019
then come back
and take another vote,
800
00:31:31,063 --> 00:31:32,978
since it seems like
801
00:31:33,021 --> 00:31:34,980
we're all on the same page now.
802
00:31:40,246 --> 00:31:42,335
Dante, what's up?
803
00:31:42,378 --> 00:31:43,902
I got you a meeting
with Tim Colvin.
804
00:31:43,945 --> 00:31:45,425
What happened to "taking time"?
805
00:31:45,468 --> 00:31:46,513
Don't read into it.
806
00:31:46,556 --> 00:31:47,775
Wouldn't dare.
807
00:31:47,818 --> 00:31:49,516
But I'm glad you did.
808
00:31:49,559 --> 00:31:50,996
I have a few questions for Tim.
809
00:31:51,039 --> 00:31:52,475
What's wrong?
810
00:31:52,519 --> 00:31:54,390
In his testimony,
811
00:31:54,434 --> 00:31:56,349
Tim said Sarah's building
looked warm and inviting,
812
00:31:56,392 --> 00:31:58,133
which is why he ducked in,
813
00:31:58,177 --> 00:32:00,919
but the indoor lights are
on motion sensors.
814
00:32:00,962 --> 00:32:03,008
So if no one was
coming or going,
815
00:32:03,051 --> 00:32:04,705
it would've looked
cold and dark,
816
00:32:04,748 --> 00:32:06,750
which means he lied.
817
00:32:06,794 --> 00:32:08,448
Why would he lie about that?
818
00:32:08,491 --> 00:32:10,319
Maybe because someone was there.
819
00:32:10,363 --> 00:32:11,973
Maybe because he actually did
820
00:32:12,017 --> 00:32:13,975
follow Sarah into the building.
821
00:32:14,019 --> 00:32:16,238
Maybe he's not innocent at all.
822
00:32:22,375 --> 00:32:24,681
What was I supposed to do?
823
00:32:24,725 --> 00:32:25,769
Tell the truth?
824
00:32:25,813 --> 00:32:28,816
The cops had me at the scene.
825
00:32:28,859 --> 00:32:30,687
I didn't even tell my attorney.
826
00:32:30,731 --> 00:32:32,472
Well, since we're not cops,
827
00:32:32,515 --> 00:32:34,474
why don't you tell us
what really happened.
828
00:32:36,302 --> 00:32:38,695
Sarah did let me
into the building that night.
829
00:32:38,739 --> 00:32:41,089
She was drunk and heading in.
830
00:32:41,133 --> 00:32:44,179
And it looked warm,
so I followed her in.
831
00:32:44,223 --> 00:32:47,008
And I asked if she was okay,
and she said she was fine,
832
00:32:47,052 --> 00:32:48,705
and then she headed
up the stairs.
833
00:32:48,749 --> 00:32:49,880
You know how that sounds.
834
00:32:49,924 --> 00:32:51,404
Of course I do.
835
00:32:52,709 --> 00:32:54,407
But I didn't kill her.
836
00:32:54,450 --> 00:32:56,757
You know what
they were arresting me for.
837
00:32:56,800 --> 00:32:59,325
If I had admitted
that she let me in that night,
838
00:32:59,368 --> 00:33:01,022
I would've been digging
my own grave.
839
00:33:01,066 --> 00:33:03,111
What happened
after she let you in?
840
00:33:03,155 --> 00:33:05,853
She went on her way,
841
00:33:05,896 --> 00:33:07,376
and I stayed in the vestibule,
842
00:33:07,420 --> 00:33:09,335
warming up
until I caught the cab.
843
00:33:09,378 --> 00:33:11,815
I know I shouldn't have lied,
844
00:33:11,859 --> 00:33:13,992
but I'm not the only one.
845
00:33:15,471 --> 00:33:18,518
I heard the prosecution's
narrative in the court.
846
00:33:21,129 --> 00:33:23,001
You know what they're doing.
847
00:33:23,044 --> 00:33:24,350
I do know.
848
00:33:24,393 --> 00:33:26,004
I keep thinking,
849
00:33:26,047 --> 00:33:28,093
if I hadn't fought
with Morgan that night,
850
00:33:28,136 --> 00:33:31,052
hadn't gone in that building,
851
00:33:31,096 --> 00:33:33,011
hadn't tripped on that trash
and cut my hand
852
00:33:33,054 --> 00:33:34,447
while running to catch the cab,
853
00:33:34,490 --> 00:33:36,362
maybe I wouldn't be here
right now.
854
00:33:36,405 --> 00:33:39,582
Wait, what'd you say
you tripped over?
855
00:33:39,626 --> 00:33:41,976
Garbage day is Tuesday.
So what?
856
00:33:43,325 --> 00:33:46,154
So they would've put the bags
out on the street on Monday.
857
00:33:46,198 --> 00:33:48,461
Same night Sarah was murdered.
858
00:33:48,504 --> 00:33:50,724
Harry, can you find me photos
from Sarah's street
859
00:33:50,767 --> 00:33:52,639
- from last Monday night?
- Yeah, they just put a new street cam up
860
00:33:52,682 --> 00:33:53,988
a couple months ago.
861
00:33:54,032 --> 00:33:56,121
Here we go.
862
00:33:56,164 --> 00:33:57,600
So, this is what it
would have looked like
863
00:33:57,644 --> 00:33:59,037
the night Tim ran for the cab.
864
00:33:59,080 --> 00:34:00,864
- What are we looking for?
- That.
865
00:34:00,908 --> 00:34:03,171
Christian's window.
You see it?
866
00:34:03,215 --> 00:34:05,173
The garbage is blocking
the view.
867
00:34:05,217 --> 00:34:06,566
So Christian wouldn't
have been able
868
00:34:06,609 --> 00:34:09,003
to see Tim
run for the cab.
869
00:34:09,047 --> 00:34:10,613
But Christian did see Tim.
870
00:34:10,657 --> 00:34:12,659
ID'ing the cab was
how the cops found him.
871
00:34:12,702 --> 00:34:15,096
Well, why would Christian lie
about where he saw him from?
872
00:34:16,271 --> 00:34:18,230
Harry, run a background check
on Christian.
873
00:34:18,273 --> 00:34:19,666
And hurry up.
874
00:34:19,709 --> 00:34:21,668
Aunt Vi's running out of time.
875
00:34:24,062 --> 00:34:27,456
Seems like we're all
in agreement.
876
00:34:27,500 --> 00:34:28,849
So...
877
00:34:28,892 --> 00:34:30,285
all voting to acquit?
878
00:34:32,896 --> 00:34:34,507
Oh, please.
879
00:34:34,550 --> 00:34:36,422
No.
880
00:34:36,465 --> 00:34:38,250
You're still voting "guilty"?
881
00:34:38,293 --> 00:34:40,730
But we just blew holes
through every piece of evidence.
882
00:34:40,774 --> 00:34:42,645
You can twist the evidence
any way you want.
883
00:34:42,689 --> 00:34:43,907
To me, it is
what it is.
884
00:34:43,951 --> 00:34:46,432
But we can't be sure it is.
885
00:34:46,475 --> 00:34:48,869
Yeah. No one's saying
they're sure he's innocent,
886
00:34:48,912 --> 00:34:50,088
but it's reasonable to think
887
00:34:50,131 --> 00:34:51,915
- he might not have done it.
- Thanks.
888
00:34:51,959 --> 00:34:54,048
I do understand the concept
of "reasonable doubt."
889
00:34:54,092 --> 00:34:55,832
Look, why don't we
go over it again.
890
00:34:55,876 --> 00:34:57,486
Maybe if we just... No.
891
00:34:58,705 --> 00:35:00,141
I don't need to go
over it again.
892
00:35:00,185 --> 00:35:02,622
I don't need it to
be explained to me.
893
00:35:02,665 --> 00:35:05,799
I know guys like this,
and I see him for who he is.
894
00:35:07,801 --> 00:35:09,542
COURT OFFICER:Jurors.
895
00:35:09,585 --> 00:35:11,631
The judge is asking if
you're approaching a decision.
896
00:35:11,674 --> 00:35:13,502
Uh...
897
00:35:13,546 --> 00:35:15,287
Could we just have
another minute?
898
00:35:25,558 --> 00:35:27,777
You said you see him
for who he is.
899
00:35:28,996 --> 00:35:30,084
Who is that?
900
00:35:30,128 --> 00:35:33,043
Someone who hurt you?
901
00:35:33,087 --> 00:35:34,871
Someone who lied to you, someone
902
00:35:34,915 --> 00:35:36,917
Who broke your trust?
903
00:35:36,960 --> 00:35:38,136
That person isn't Tim.
904
00:35:40,268 --> 00:35:41,791
He's not your ex.
905
00:35:41,835 --> 00:35:43,097
You don't know
what you're talking about.
906
00:35:43,141 --> 00:35:44,794
And you won't
change my mind.
907
00:35:44,838 --> 00:35:46,187
I'm not gonna try.
908
00:35:46,231 --> 00:35:49,495
All I've ever asked of
anyone here is
909
00:35:49,538 --> 00:35:53,063
to scrutinize the evidence
with care,
910
00:35:53,107 --> 00:35:55,327
and then vote your conscience.
911
00:35:55,370 --> 00:35:58,112
So...
912
00:35:58,156 --> 00:36:01,333
if you truly think
that Tim is guilty,
913
00:36:01,376 --> 00:36:04,727
then you should stand
in that truth
914
00:36:04,771 --> 00:36:06,294
and vote that way.
915
00:36:10,820 --> 00:36:12,605
All right, so Christian
looks clean, right?
916
00:36:12,648 --> 00:36:14,346
But you dig a little deeper,
you're gonna discover
917
00:36:14,389 --> 00:36:15,912
that he was part of a fraternity
ten years ago
918
00:36:15,956 --> 00:36:17,827
that dissolved
after rape allegations surfaced.
919
00:36:17,871 --> 00:36:19,394
- NDAs?
- Yeah. Exactly.
920
00:36:19,438 --> 00:36:20,700
No suspects were ever named.
921
00:36:20,743 --> 00:36:22,136
Then a few years ago,
922
00:36:22,180 --> 00:36:23,790
he was living in
an apartment building
923
00:36:23,833 --> 00:36:24,834
where a woman was attacked
and killed in the stairwell.
924
00:36:24,878 --> 00:36:26,662
Case went unsolved.
925
00:36:26,706 --> 00:36:29,230
Okay, so we know Christian
saw Tim get in the cab,
926
00:36:29,274 --> 00:36:31,232
but he wasn't in his apartment.
927
00:36:31,276 --> 00:36:33,930
And he wasn't in the foyer,
because Tim would've seen him.
928
00:36:33,974 --> 00:36:35,280
But there's one other place
he could've been.
929
00:36:35,323 --> 00:36:37,064
- Oh, God.
- Harry.
930
00:36:41,199 --> 00:36:42,330
There's a clear line of sight
931
00:36:42,374 --> 00:36:43,592
from Sarah's apartment
to the street.
932
00:36:43,636 --> 00:36:45,551
That's why Christian lied.
933
00:36:45,594 --> 00:36:47,379
He should be the one on trial.
934
00:36:47,422 --> 00:36:48,771
Speaking of which,
they're calling the jury
935
00:36:48,815 --> 00:36:50,382
back in, looks like
they have a verdict.
936
00:36:54,603 --> 00:36:56,344
I know that look.
937
00:36:56,388 --> 00:36:58,433
I got a real suspect.
938
00:36:58,477 --> 00:37:01,610
He looks good for it
but nothing concrete.
939
00:37:01,654 --> 00:37:05,527
So, I guess it's all
in the hands of the jury.
940
00:37:20,673 --> 00:37:22,544
Ladies and gentlemen,
941
00:37:22,588 --> 00:37:23,893
welcome back.
Mr. Desoto,
942
00:37:23,937 --> 00:37:26,853
you are the jury foreperson,
correct?
943
00:37:26,896 --> 00:37:28,768
Yes, Your Honor.
944
00:37:28,811 --> 00:37:30,117
I understand you've been unable
945
00:37:30,160 --> 00:37:31,814
to reach a verdict
on either charge.
946
00:37:31,858 --> 00:37:33,251
Is that the case?
947
00:37:33,294 --> 00:37:34,774
At least it's not "guilty."
948
00:37:34,817 --> 00:37:36,210
Yeah, but if the next jury
is not willing
949
00:37:36,254 --> 00:37:37,603
to ask the hard questions,
950
00:37:37,646 --> 00:37:39,344
odds are,
951
00:37:39,387 --> 00:37:41,302
he'll be convicted.
952
00:37:41,346 --> 00:37:42,695
Mr. Desoto,
if I were to return you
953
00:37:42,738 --> 00:37:45,306
to the jury room,
do you think
954
00:37:45,350 --> 00:37:46,655
you could make progress
towards a verdict?
955
00:37:51,878 --> 00:37:53,619
No, Your Honor.
956
00:37:53,662 --> 00:37:56,317
I want to remind you all
of your duty to this court.
957
00:37:56,361 --> 00:37:58,624
And that is,
for you all to decide
958
00:37:58,667 --> 00:38:00,495
the case for yourself.
959
00:38:01,757 --> 00:38:04,020
Now, with that said,
your jury foreperson
960
00:38:04,064 --> 00:38:07,110
has stated that you've done
all you can to reach a verdict.
961
00:38:07,154 --> 00:38:10,679
If any of you disagree
with that,
962
00:38:10,723 --> 00:38:12,377
you'd better tell me now.
963
00:38:25,999 --> 00:38:27,348
In that case...
964
00:38:27,392 --> 00:38:28,523
Wait.
965
00:38:32,135 --> 00:38:33,267
I want to change my vote.
966
00:38:38,141 --> 00:38:39,534
Mr. Desoto, it appears
967
00:38:39,578 --> 00:38:41,231
to me that
from your correspondence
968
00:38:41,275 --> 00:38:43,103
on behalf of all the jurors
969
00:38:43,146 --> 00:38:44,670
that this makes
the jury's verdict
970
00:38:44,713 --> 00:38:46,846
on both charges unanimous.
971
00:38:46,889 --> 00:38:48,326
Uh...
972
00:38:48,369 --> 00:38:49,501
Yes, Your Honor.
973
00:38:50,893 --> 00:38:52,286
And what is that verdict?
974
00:38:53,722 --> 00:38:54,723
Not guilty.
975
00:38:54,767 --> 00:38:56,551
In that case,
976
00:38:56,595 --> 00:38:57,683
ladies and gentlemen
of the jury,
977
00:38:57,726 --> 00:38:59,467
this case has now concluded,
978
00:38:59,511 --> 00:39:00,555
and the court wishes
to express its appreciation
979
00:39:00,599 --> 00:39:02,296
to you for your services.
980
00:39:04,254 --> 00:39:06,779
Mr. Colvin,
you are free to go.
981
00:39:09,608 --> 00:39:10,696
All rise.
982
00:39:32,195 --> 00:39:33,762
Thanks for the assist today.
983
00:39:33,806 --> 00:39:36,156
And for what it's worth,
984
00:39:36,199 --> 00:39:38,245
I think you'd make
a great lawyer.
985
00:39:39,899 --> 00:39:41,204
Hmm.
986
00:39:49,038 --> 00:39:50,344
Congratulations.
987
00:39:50,388 --> 00:39:52,999
Jury got it right this time.
988
00:39:53,042 --> 00:39:55,131
Which means there's a guilty
man walking around out there.
989
00:39:55,175 --> 00:39:58,134
And there will continue to be.
990
00:39:58,178 --> 00:40:00,528
They think they got it right.
The A.D.A., the NYPD--
991
00:40:00,572 --> 00:40:02,269
they think Tim got
992
00:40:02,312 --> 00:40:05,446
a get-out-of-jail-free
card today.
993
00:40:05,490 --> 00:40:07,100
Which means this case
will never be reinvestigated,
994
00:40:07,143 --> 00:40:08,406
and Sarah's family
995
00:40:08,449 --> 00:40:10,538
will never get
any kind of closure.
996
00:40:32,386 --> 00:40:33,431
Mom?
997
00:40:33,474 --> 00:40:34,606
Hey, Dad's almost here.
998
00:40:34,649 --> 00:40:35,650
I'm gonna wait for him outside.
999
00:40:35,694 --> 00:40:37,304
Okay. Hey, hold up a second.
1000
00:40:41,961 --> 00:40:44,180
I want to apologize
for putting you in a position
1001
00:40:44,224 --> 00:40:45,747
to have to lie to your father.
1002
00:40:45,791 --> 00:40:48,271
Mom, I told you.
It is not a big deal.
1003
00:40:48,315 --> 00:40:50,012
It is a big deal.
1004
00:40:50,056 --> 00:40:52,493
It's true
that lies can be necessary
1005
00:40:52,537 --> 00:40:54,060
to protect your family,
1006
00:40:54,103 --> 00:40:56,671
but they can backfire on you.
1007
00:40:56,715 --> 00:40:58,107
They can hurt you
and those around you
1008
00:40:58,151 --> 00:41:00,022
in ways you never anticipate.
1009
00:41:00,066 --> 00:41:02,111
Lying is dangerous,
1010
00:41:02,155 --> 00:41:03,896
and I just want you
to realize that.
1011
00:41:08,335 --> 00:41:10,250
Well,
1012
00:41:10,293 --> 00:41:11,904
feels more dangerous not to.
1013
00:41:11,947 --> 00:41:13,819
But...
1014
00:41:13,862 --> 00:41:15,690
I understand.
1015
00:41:15,734 --> 00:41:17,344
I do.
1016
00:41:22,436 --> 00:41:23,698
Hey, you know how
1017
00:41:23,742 --> 00:41:25,483
Dad asked me
if I felt safe here?
1018
00:41:27,093 --> 00:41:29,487
I didn't have to lie about that.
1019
00:41:35,144 --> 00:41:37,277
Mm.
1020
00:41:40,585 --> 00:41:42,369
Hey, Auntie!
1021
00:41:42,412 --> 00:41:43,849
How'd deliberations go?
1022
00:41:43,892 --> 00:41:46,286
They ended. Not guilty.
1023
00:41:46,329 --> 00:41:49,245
- Ah!
- Yeah. Thank goodness.
1024
00:41:49,289 --> 00:41:50,508
Wait, so you're back?
That's great.
1025
00:41:52,074 --> 00:41:53,815
Yeah, 'cause, you know,
we missed you.
1026
00:41:53,859 --> 00:41:56,122
Yeah?
1027
00:41:56,165 --> 00:41:58,559
I heard you got mighty familiar
with the laundry room,
1028
00:41:58,603 --> 00:42:00,648
so I think I'll just
leave the ironing
1029
00:42:00,692 --> 00:42:02,563
for you until you get back
from your dad's.
1030
00:42:02,607 --> 00:42:04,826
Yeah, no, I'm good,
but I love you.
1031
00:42:05,914 --> 00:42:07,481
I love you, baby, have fun.
1032
00:42:07,525 --> 00:42:08,743
- I love you, Aunt Vi.
- I love you more.
1033
00:42:08,787 --> 00:42:11,093
Bye.
1034
00:42:14,880 --> 00:42:16,838
Well, I can't say
that I was surprised
1035
00:42:16,882 --> 00:42:18,710
to see you in the courtroom today.
1036
00:42:18,753 --> 00:42:21,190
I may have followed the case,
1037
00:42:21,234 --> 00:42:23,149
but that young man
1038
00:42:23,192 --> 00:42:25,064
owes his freedom to you.
1039
00:42:26,065 --> 00:42:27,545
Well...
1040
00:42:28,720 --> 00:42:30,373
I just did what was
required of me.
1041
00:42:30,417 --> 00:42:32,288
♪ I see all the light
1042
00:42:32,332 --> 00:42:34,726
♪ That lifts us
1043
00:42:34,769 --> 00:42:38,077
Now, see, that's what
the world needs more of:
1044
00:42:38,120 --> 00:42:40,209
that.
1045
00:42:40,253 --> 00:42:43,256
People willing to take
the time and the trouble
1046
00:42:43,299 --> 00:42:45,432
to find the truth.
1047
00:42:51,003 --> 00:42:53,005
Got a minute?
1048
00:42:53,048 --> 00:42:55,007
Detective Dante.
1049
00:42:55,050 --> 00:42:56,661
NYPD.
1050
00:42:56,704 --> 00:42:58,401
I have a few questions for you.
1051
00:42:58,445 --> 00:43:00,752
♪ We'll all be, we'll all be
1052
00:43:00,795 --> 00:43:02,797
♪ We'll all be all right.
1053
00:43:09,630 --> 00:43:12,328
Captioning sponsored by CBS
1054
00:43:15,636 --> 00:43:19,422
Captioned by
Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org